Agariyas of the Santalpur block of Gujarat's Patan district have alleged discrimination by the Forest Department officials in granting permits to enter the Little Rann of Kutch (LRK) for salt farming. 

In September 2023, the state government allowed salt pan workers with leases up to 10 acres to continue their traditional salt production in LRK. Since then, several Agariyas from Dhandhdhra, Halwad, and Patadi were given permission to enter the LRK, but none of the 1,200 salt farmers from the Santalpur side of Patan district were allowed to enter the area. 

Agariyas, the traditional salt farmers, have been harvesting salt in the Little Rann of Kutch for decades. The typical salt farming season starts around Dushera in October, but even after two months, the salt farmers were still waiting for the permission. "The Forest Department told us that they need some time to verify and finalize the list ... thus we were waiting. We do not have any other source of livelihood and today sit ideal at home," Narubhai Koli, who has been farming salt for six generations, from the Santalpur Rann was quoted as saying.

The Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (PCCF) (Wildlife) Nityanand Srivastava said, “We are allowing only those whose name are there in the settlement report”, though underlining, only those “eligible for one well” will be permitted to do salt farming. However, salt farmers claim their names are mentioned in the government survey and settlement records.

Bharat Singh Dabhi, Lok Sabha Member from Patan, also wrote a letter to the Chief Minister of Gujarat highlighting the fact that Agariyas from his constituency have been denied entry into the LRK despite them being officially listed in government survey and settlement records. He added that the discrepancy in allowing salt farmers from one side while denying access to those from another side within the same LRK raises questions about the Forest Department's operations.

Meanwhile, the Gujarat High Court on January 18, 2024 directed the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests to submit a reply by 29 January in response to a petition filed by members of Agariya community. The court emphasised that Agariyas who possess identity cards, should be permitted to engage in salt farming, as it constitutes their livelihood. The Court found no valid reason, based on the available records, to deny them access to the desert.

The Survey and Settlement Report was prepared to seek a grant from the World Bank to conserve biodiversity of the LRK’s Wild Ass Sanctuary. The report, initiated in September 1997 and completed in 2016, left out a large number of Agariyas from the list, prompting their demand for inclusion. Reportedly, only 189 Agariyas were included in the list for Santalpur block, as against estimates of up to 1,200. 

After the settlement report was released, representatives of aggrieved Agariyas submitted a memorandum to the chief minister, attaching historic documents dating back to the British era and showcasing the community's involvement in salt cultivation. Following which, on 4 September 2023, the state government decided to allow all traditional Agariyas to continue salt harvesting upon simple registration, the verification of which would be done during on-site survey. It was also decided that the survey and settlement process list would be revised by doing on-site survey so that seasonal user rights were recognised on a permanent basis.

In 1973, approximately 4000 square kilometers of LRK was designated as a Wild Ass Sanctuary (WAS), protecting the Indian wild ass, exclusively found in the Kutch region of Gujarat. However, the presence of Agariyas was viewed as a threat to wildlife protection efforts, leading to eviction notices, restricted access to welfare schemes, and a lack of livelihood insurance during natural disasters.

Agariyas, however, claim that there is no conflict between them and wild ass, as census data shows a significant increase in the wild ass population from 700 in 1973 to 6,082 in 2019.

The Santlapur's Agariya community sent a letter to the Prime Minister on 23 December 2023 saying that despite numerous appeals to state authorities, including the Chief Minister, Forest Minister, and Forest Department officials, they continue to be unjustly barred from accessing salt pans.

They added that MP of Patan Bharat Singh Dabhi Saheb and Radhnpur MLA Lavingji Thakore, have written letters to the authoritites, but their situation remains unresolved. "Despite our area's consistent support for the BJP, we are left bewildered by the persisting injustice," the letter read.

They further said that livelihoods of 2 lakh people are at stake, with 1,000 Agariyas and their families facing dire circumstances. The cessation of salt production has caused labourers from other states working in factories and railway stations to return home, exacerbating the economic downturn in our community.

The community warned that if their desperate plea continues to fall on deaf ears, 200 of them would personally appeal at the PMO House in Delhi.

The Gujarat Government on February 13 submitted an affidavit in the High Court, stating that individuals intending to cultivate salt within the Wild Ass Sanctuary must obtain prior permission by acquiring an 'Agariya card'. This card is exclusively issued to individuals, entities, or cooperative societies listed in the Survey Settlement Report issued by the sanctuary's settlement officer.

According to the affidavit filed by Dhavalkumar Gadhavi, the Deputy Conservator of Forest (DCF) at the Wild Ass Sanctuary in Dhrangadhra, Surendranagar, the petitioners' names are not mentioned in the 2008 Survey Settlement Report, and they do not possess the required Agariya cards issued by the Forest Department. Only those salt workers possessing such cards are permitted to enter the sanctuary for salt cultivation.

The petitioners, however, assert that they are traditional Agariyas (salt pan cultivators) from Santalpur in Patan's Little Rann of Kutch. They claim to have been cultivating salt there since 2008 and were issued Agariya pothi—a card identifying them as salt pan cultivators. However, the affidavit emphasizes that the Agariya pothi serves merely as an "identification card" for accessing welfare schemes and holds no legal validity for other purposes.